Sequentially numbered endnotes provide the information most needed at each juncture, while a detailed index of terms guides the reader to places where focused discussion of key notions occurs. Aug 15, 1991 this volume contains a close translation, suitable for students without a knowledge of greek, of the seventh and eighth books of aristotle s metaphysics, together with a thorough and careful philosophical commentary. This is a new type of commentary to aristotle s key text, entitled metaphysics after his death. Discover delightful childrens books with amazon book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new amazon book box prime. Metaphysics hardcover aristotle oxford university press. Stefan grossmann aristotle s metaphysics a commentary vol 2. Averroes tafsir and the book alpha meizon arabic metaphysics. Metaphysics aristotle project gutenberg selfpublishing. But since we are in search of this science, it will therefore be necessary to consider with what kind of causes and principles wisdom or science deals. Metaphysics by aristotle, part of the internet classics archive. Pdf aquinass commentary on the metaphysics gabriele. This book will remain timeless in its study of aristotle s objective grasp of reality. Madigans accompanying introduction and commentary give detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of. This is shown by the fact that whereas no one person can obtain an adequate grasp of it.
Metaphysics paperback aristotle oxford university press. A translation with introduction of ibn rushds commentary on aristotle s metaphysics, book lam, brill, leiden 1984. Metaphysics by aristotle book viii classical wisdom. Aristotle metaphysics free ebooks download ebookee. Aristotle himself provides no answers to the puzzles but rather takes them as examples of extreme positions between which he will try to mediate throughout the rest of the metaphysics. I agree with the author that there are principles of causes, and before the causes, we have substances. A commentary on book alpha elatton of aristotles metaphysics 2 demand the language we are accustomed to, and that which is different from this seems not in keeping but somewhat unintelligible. The aristotle s metaphysics community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. The metaphysics is considered to be one of the greatest philosophical works.
The term metaphysics meant after physics, because this particular work of aristotle was published after another famous work of aristotle, known as physics. In chapter 2 aristotle rehashes what a substance might be. Aquinas uses the right reference from the beginning of his commentary on book vii. Before he draws any grand conclusions, he begins with the idea of substance, of which there are three kinds. Not surprisingly, the topics discussed in the book the scientific status of ontology and metaphysics, the foundations of logical truths, the notions of essence and existence, the nature of material objects and their properties, the status of mathematical entities, just to mention some are still at the centre of the current philosophical. In these difficult books, which are central to his metaphysical system, aristotle discusses the nature of perceptible reality. Laura castellis commentary has the merit of filling an important gap in aristotelian scholarship, offering an analysis which appeals both to the philosopher and to the historian of philosophy. Book gamma asserts that philosophy, especially metaphysics, is the study of being qua being. An indication of this is the delight we take in our senses. Part 1 beginning means 1 that part of a thing from which one would start first, e. Averroes long commentary on the metaphysics online by cecilia martini bonadeo 25072012 10. Aristotle replies that the idea of an infinite causal series is absurd, and thus there must be a first cause which is not itself caused. A commentary on book alpha elatton of aristotle s metaphysics 4 thinking allows for a true development in the historical evolution of thought and the possibility of the fulfilment of our desire to know. We have said that the causes, principles, and elements of substances are.
The purpose of this chapter is to address a possible objection to aristotles account of how we understand first principles and thus acquire wisdom. Commentary on the metaphysics by thomas aquinas translated by john p. Commentary on aristotles metaphysics aristotelian commentary. Book 1 the work itself 692663 what previous philosophers said about causes 69272 determination of the truth 2732663 book 2 with regard to universal truth 274337 with regard to the truth about what belongs to this science 3382663 book 3.
Aristotle will spend some of the metaphysics criticizing platos notion of the forms, but the reader may note that the discussion about the existence of forms continues to this day. Ibn rushds metaphysics meet your next favorite book. Thomas aquinass justly renowned commentary, written at the peak of his scholarly life, illuminates what is obscure in aristotle s text. In the wellknown chapter 9 of book alpha, aristotle begins his criticism of platos theory of forms. Read download aristotles metaphysics pdf pdf download. So first philosophy studies the causes and principles of beings qua beings. New approaches to the book alpha meizon of aristotles.
This is the only commentary on aristotle s theological work, metaphysics, book 12, to survive from the first six centuries ce the heyday of ancient greek commentary on aristotle. That is, while other sciences investigate limited aspects of being. The only ancient commentaries at our disposal were not written until the 12th centuryin greek probably by michael of ephesus and in arabic by averroes. Arthur madigan presents a clear, accurate new translation of the third book beta of aristotle s metaphysics, together with two related chapters from the eleventh book kappa. Some philosophers thought substance was found in physical bodies, such as those of animals and plants, as well as in more elemental ones, such as fire, earth, water, and air. The two most interesting things about this work are the fact that averroes. Aristotle notes parenthetically another important aspect of his theo.
Reviewed by christopher shields, university of colorado at boulder. The book s uniqueness lies in its aim of letting aquinas himself speak on the subject of metaphysics. Zeta to the end of book xii lambda, and in books ii and iii. Cecilia martini averroes long commentary on the bonadeo, university of pisa metaphysics online by cecilia martini bonadeo a license agreement between the publisher dar elmashreq and greek into arabic grants access to the volumes of the series. Aristotle translated with a commentary by arthur madigan, s.
Alexander of aphrodisias and the text of aristotles. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takesto be the main problems of metaphysics or first philosophy and assesses possible solutions to. Aristotle, metaphysics, book 2 993a the study of truth is in one sense difficult, in another easy. References in the text to the books of aristotles metaphysics are given. The following are detailed notes of aristotles metaphysics, which were part of a summer project grant, approved by the maricopa. Castelli presents a new translation and comprehensive commentary of the tenth book iota of aristotle s metaphysics, which provides aristotle s most systematic account of what it is for something to be one, what it is for something to be a unit of measurement, what contraries are, and what the function of contraries is in shaping the. Feb 11, 2016 this new translation of aristotle s metaphysics in its entirety is a model of accuracy and consistency, presented with a wealth of annotation and commentary. The study of truth is in one sense difficult, in another easy. Ross book viii part 1 we must reckon up the results arising from what has been said, and compute the sum of them, and put the finishing touch to our inquiry. Volume two makes available to scholars one of the culminating points in the medieval reception of aristotle s metaphysical thought by presenting the first critical edition of book vii of paul of venices commentary on aristotle s metaphysics 14201424. Stefan grossmann aristotle s metaphysics a commentary vol. Laura castellis commentary has the merit of filling an important gap in aristotelian scholarship, offering an analysis which appeals both to the. Some remarks on averroes long commentary on the metaphysics. Averroes three commentaries on aristotles metaphysics.
But since that which has the character of a subject or matter has been admitted by all to be substance, and this is what is in potentiality, it remains to explain what it is that constitutes the substance of sensible things in the sense of actuality. Though the greek text itself is lost, a full english translation is presented here for the first time, based on arabic versions of the greek and a hebrew version of the arabic. We will explain this connection in section 3 below. Book xii, on the other hand, is usually considered the culmination of aristotle s work in metaphysics, and in it he offers his teleological system. The principal subject is being qua being, or being insofar as it is being. This paper aims at explaining about the commentary on the book alpha meizon, the second in original greek, first book of averroes long commentary on the metaphysics. Castelli presents a new translation and comprehensive commentary of the tenth book iota of aristotle s metaphysics, which provides aristotle s most systematic account of what it is for something to be one, what it is for something to be a unit of measurement, what contraries are, and what the function of contraries is in shaping the structure of reality into genera and species.
The absence of such a commentary reflects the fact that the explosion of aristotelian scholarship in the last halfcentury has left these texts largely. Aristotle notes metaphysics mesa community college. Aristotle thinks this is one reason to reject the theory of forms. In three volumes, burning modern issues are worked in, revealing the lost ancient meaning as a meditation text of inner alchemy the middle books and logical cosmology the late books. Only later, after having read alfarabis, purposes of the metaphysics of aristotle, did he understand aristotle s book. We can solve the puzzle about how elements in a definition are unified by saying that matter and form are one, as potentiality to actuality. The annenberg cpbproject provided support for entering this text. The author was a magnificent philosopher, and the writing covers many subjects, including metaphysics, biology, logic and zoology. This will perhaps become evident if we take the opinions which we have about the wise man. Go to previous table of contents book ii, go to next. Introductionas is known, thomas aquinas set out to comment on aristotle s works rather late in his career. The best text we have is the early printed iunctas edition of 15621574, which contains scots translation of the long commentary interspersed with two translations of the metaphysics, one of. The commentary on book 1 has the further interest that over half of it is devoted to aristotle s discussion of plato.
The internet classics archive metaphysics by aristotle. Alexander of aphrodisias was the greatest exponent of aristotelianism after aristotle, and his commentary on metaphysics 15 is the most substantial commentary on the metaphysics to have survived from antiquity. Aristotle 384332322 aristotle, one of the greatest minds of the classical period, was brought up in an aristocratic household in macedonia. Commentary on metaphysics books 712 latinenglish opera. Prayers to the god of aristotle s metaphysics halper, yehuda, prayers to the god of aristotle s metaphysics. One and many in aristotle s metaphysics halper, edward, one and many in aristotle s metaphysics, alpha delta, parmenides press, 2009. Metaphysics, the book as a result, some of aristotle s views on subjects we now consider to be a part of metaphysics are found elsewhere. This is a new type of commentary to aristotles key text, entitled metaphysics after his death. Read download commentary on aristotles metaphysics pdf pdf. Here aristotle is expanding his account of the role of actuality and potentiality. The work embraces both a history of philosophy and aristotle s subsequent reasoning toward god as pure act. This volume presents a commentary on aristotle s metaphysics book 12 by pseudoalexander in a new translation accompanied by explanatory notes, introduction and indexes. Though the greek text itself is lost, a full english translation is presented here for the first time, based on arabic versions of the greek and a hebrew version of.
Click anywhere in the line to jump to another position. These two puzzles have been raised in the notes on books. A commentary on book alpha elatton of aristotles metaphysics. Volume two makes available to scholars one of the culminating points in the medieval reception of aristotles metaphysical thought by presenting the first critical edition of book vii of paul of venices commentary on aristotles metaphysics 14201424. However, since the difficulty is twofold, perhaps its cause is not in things but in us. When he was around 18 he went to athens to study with plato at the academy where he remained for 20 years until platos death in 347.
In other words, aquinas took what aristotle espoused in his metaphysics and discussed it in great detail. The twelfth book of aristotle s metaphysics, metaphysics lambda, is in several respects crucial to our understanding not only of aristotle s entire metaphysical system but of central developments in the subsequent history of metaphysical theology taken as a whole in the first instance, in terms internal to his own metaphysical schema, metaphysics lambda seems to answer the demand for an. The first book of aristotle s metaphysics is attributed. The fine editions of the aristotelian commentary series make available long out ofprint commentaries of st.
In other words, aquinas took what aristotle espoused in his metaphysics. The purpose of this chapter is to address a possible objection to aristotle s account of how we understand first principles and thus acquire wisdom. Its influence on the greeks, the muslim philosophers, the scholastic philosophers and even writers such as dante, was immense. The book is a phrase by phraseparagraph by paragraph commentary written by aquinas on aristotle s actual work. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first philosophy and assesses possible solutions to.
In 2, aristotle adds that for this reason it studies the causes and principles of substances ousiai. This book contains the first english translation of abulwalid ibn rushds averroes. Aristotles metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. It examines what can be asserted about any being insofar as it is and not because of any. Pdf averroes long commentary on the metaphysics online. A most ample index to the metaphysics of aristotle index locupletissimus in metaphysicam aristotelis francisco suarez, john p. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first philosophy and assesses possible solutions to them. It is essentially a reconciliation of platos theory of forms that aristotle acquired at the academy in athens, with the view of the world given by common sense and the observations. Madigans accompanying introduction and commentary give detailed guidance to these texts. We should study nature as a form in a matter like snubness, which is a certain shape in a certain matter, i. Madigans accompanying commentary gives detailed guidance to these texts, in which aristotle sets out what he takes to be the main problems of metaphysics or first. Book alpha meizon of aristotle s metaphysics and to its unique neoplatonic commentary by asclepius of tralles r. The original arabic text was composed around 1160 by the famous andalusian philosopher averroes ibn rushd.
The tenth book iota is by far one of the least studied, and commented upon, of aristotle s metaphysics. Loredana cardullo a cura di, il libro alpha della metafisica di aristotele tra storiografia e teoria, catania 2009, pp. Aristotle s metaphysics is foundational for the philosophical study of those speculative objects that extend beyond the realm of natural science. In 2, aristotle adds that for this reason it studies the causes and. First, this is not articulated as an explicit argument. The fifteenpage translation of aristotle s central text on potentiality and actuality paired with some 285 pages of commentary including the introduction strikes a fair balance. He looks at previous answers from various schools of thought. Nowhere is this more evident than in the metaphysics ibn sina avicenna, one of the greatest medieval islamic philosophers, said that he had read the metaphysics of aristotle forty times, but still did not understand it. There is no modern edition of scots translation of either aristotle s metaphysics or averroess long commentary on the metaphysics. Dec 01, 1986 this book contains the first english translation of an important medieval treatise on aristotle s metaphysics. A revised text with introduction and commentary volume 1 of aristotles meta physics, a revised text with introduction and commentary by w. Stephen makin has produced an interesting and demanding contribution to the clarendon aristotle series. Ibn sinas metaphysics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
795 29 885 557 105 478 1037 315 818 907 181 414 1470 374 227 690 1501 458 519 1555 641 1073 715 1581 1208 1374 1276 1062